Green Roofs and Walls: Improving Urban Biodiversity and Sustainability
Modern cities are grappling with complex environmental challenges such as air pollution, urban heat islands, and the accelerated loss of biodiversity. These issues, intensified by rapid urbanization and high population density, threaten the health of urban ecosystems and the quality of life for city residents. In response to these challenges, nature-based solutions, particularly green roofs and walls, are gaining traction as vital tools for promoting a more sustainable urban environment.
By seamlessly integrating with existing infrastructure, green roofing and wall systems offer far more than aesthetic appeal: they act as thermal insulators, reducing the energy demands of buildings, and play a crucial role in absorbing rainwater, thereby mitigating the risks of urban flooding. Additionally, these vertical green spaces support biodiversity by creating habitats for urban wildlife, thereby enhancing local ecosystems.
This article examines the ecological and economic benefits of green roofs and walls, demonstrating how their implementation contributes to the development of more resilient and environmentally-friendly cities.
Green Roofs and Walls: Definitions and Types
Green roofs and walls are architectural solutions that integrate vegetation into built surfaces to create functional green spaces, contributing to the enhancement of the urban environment. These systems, increasingly adopted in sustainable development projects, play a key role in mitigating urban heat islands, enhancing biodiversity, and managing stormwater runoff [1].
Differentiation of Green Roof Types
Green roofs come in various typologies depending on the depth of the substrate, the types of plants used, and their intended application:
Extensive Green Roofs:
These roofs consist of low-maintenance vegetation, often succulents and sedums, requiring a relatively shallow substrate depth (between 5 and 15 cm). Extensive green roofs are lightweight, suitable for existing roofs, and require minimal watering. Their primary advantage lies in their ability to thermally insulate buildings while providing a resilient and durable vegetative cover.
Semi-Intensive Green Roofs:
This type of green roof serves as a compromise between extensive and intensive roofs. With an intermediate substrate depth (15 to 30 cm), they can support a wider variety of plants, including grasses and perennial plants. They require moderate maintenance, particularly regarding watering and fertilization, but offer greater ecological diversity.
Intensive Green Roofs:
Often referred to as "hanging gardens," these roofs require a thick substrate (more than 30 cm) and can support trees, shrubs, and even garden equipment. They are akin to fully accessible urban green spaces, encouraging recreational activities. However, their weight and maintenance demands necessitate reinforced structural design and intensive management, particularly for irrigation and drainage.
Green Walls: Typologies and Systems
Green walls [2] represent another approach to integrating nature into architecture by covering building façades with plants. They are generally classified into two main systems:
Felt Systems:
Initially developed by botanist Patrick Blanc, these systems utilize layers of non-woven felt to support vegetation. Plants are inserted into pockets within the felt, and water is supplied through a drip irrigation system. These green walls are often used for aesthetic purposes but also contribute to the thermal regulation of buildings.
Modular Panels:
This type of green wall uses prefabricated modules, typically made of plastic or metal, which contain substrate and plants. The panels are assembled onto the façade, making installation and maintenance easier. Modular systems allow for greater flexibility in plant selection and are often more durable than felt systems. They are employed to enhance the thermal and acoustic insulation of buildings while simultaneously increasing urban biodiversity.
Historical Evolution and Urban Adoption of Green Roofs and Walls
The use of green roofs and walls is not a new concept. Its origins trace back to antiquity, with the famous Hanging Gardens of Babylon, one of the Seven Wonders of the Ancient World. Although these gardens are largely mythical, they reflect an ancient desire to integrate nature into human-made structures. [3] [4]
In recent decades, the popularity of green roofs and walls has grown significantly, supported by environmental policies promoting sustainable construction. Cities like Singapore, with its "City in a Garden" program [5], have embraced these solutions to mitigate urban heat islands, improve air quality, and enhance biodiversity.
These recent examples illustrate how the adoption of green roofs and walls is part of an integrated approach to urban planning, where aesthetics and functionality merge to address current environmental challenges.
Environmental Benefits of Green Roofs and Walls
Green roofs and walls are far more than aesthetic features; they represent technical solutions capable of addressing many environmental challenges, particularly urban biodiversity, thermal insulation, and stormwater management. [6]
Enhancing Urban Biodiversity
Green roofs and walls play a crucial role in promoting biodiversity in urban environments. By introducing diverse vegetation onto built surfaces, these installations provide favorable habitats for various plant and animal species, often threatened by urbanization. For example, native plants and nectar-producing species attract pollinators like bees and butterflies, which find refuge in these green spaces. Additionally, birds and small insects benefit from microhabitats created by dense vegetation, contributing to the formation of ecological corridors. These corridors facilitate species movement between green areas, enhancing the resilience of urban ecosystems against anthropogenic pressures. [7]
Studies have shown that extensive green roofs, especially those composed of succulent plants like sedums, are particularly effective in attracting pollinating insects. Meanwhile, green walls, employing felt-based systems or modular panels, promote a diversity of plant species adapted to different orientations and climatic conditions, thus enriching the local fauna. These structures also help combat habitat fragmentation, a major issue affecting urban biodiversity.
Thermal Insulation and Urban Heat Island Reduction
Vegetated surfaces, whether horizontal (roofs) or vertical (walls), have a direct impact on the thermal regulation of buildings and their immediate surroundings. Plants and substrate act as insulating barriers, reducing temperature fluctuations within buildings. During summer, vegetation absorbs a portion of solar radiation, thereby limiting heat transmission through the structure. This cooling capacity not only helps mitigate the urban heat island effect but also reduces the demand for air conditioning, leading to significant energy savings.
In winter, green roofs enhance thermal insulation by minimizing heat loss, which decreases energy consumption for heating. According to studies [8] [9], buildings equipped with green roofs can experience a 10% to 30% reduction in annual energy consumption. Furthermore, cities such as Toronto, New York, and Tokyo have observed notable decreases in urban temperatures following the widespread adoption of these green infrastructures, demonstrating their effectiveness in combating urban warming.
Stormwater Management
One of the most prominent benefits of green roofs and walls is their ability to manage stormwater. In urban areas, the impermeability of surfaces increases runoff, placing pressure on drainage systems and raising the risk of flooding. Green roofs absorb a significant portion of precipitation, thereby reducing the volume of water flowing into sewers. The substrate used in these systems, made of porous materials, retains water and releases it gradually, reducing peak runoff and extending infiltration times.
Moreover, these installations improve water quality by filtering pollutants before they reach groundwater or waterways. Case studies conducted in cities like Hamburg [10] and Chicago [11] have shown that green roofs can reduce stormwater runoff by 50% to 80%, easing the burden on drainage infrastructure and contributing to more sustainable water resource management.
Socio-Economic Impacts of Green Infrastructures
Beyond their environmental benefits, green roofs and walls offer significant socio-economic impacts, underscoring the strategic investment potential of integrating green infrastructures into urban environments.
Enhancing Quality of Life and Well-being
The presence of green spaces in urban settings has demonstrated substantial positive effects on mental health and well-being. Studies [12] [13] [14] indicate that regular access to vegetation reduces stress, improves mood, and may even decrease the incidence of depressive disorders. By introducing a touch of nature into densely populated environments, green roofs and walls allow city dwellers to enjoy the calming effects of greenery without leaving the urban area. These spaces also promote leisure activities such as urban gardening, creating opportunities for communities to reconnect with nature.
Increasing Property Value
Integrating green roofs and walls also contributes to an increase in property value. These installations offer long-term financial advantages, including enhanced energy efficiency, reduced heating and cooling costs, and improved thermal insulation. Moreover, the aesthetic appeal of a building featuring a green roof or wall makes it more attractive to buyers and potential investors. Economic studies [15] [16] reveal that properties with green roofs can experience a 7% to 14% increase in value, boosting demand for such innovative projects. Return on investment is generally positive, particularly in competitive urban markets where energy efficiency and visual appeal are key factors.
Job Creation and Local Development
The development of green infrastructures also leads to the creation of new job opportunities. Installing and maintaining green roofs and walls require specialized skills, including gardeners, landscape architects, and sustainable construction technicians. These professions help stimulate the local economy and encourage training and innovation in emerging sectors. Additionally, the growing adoption of these infrastructures generates demand for new products and services, such as specialized growing substrates, smart irrigation systems, and ecological monitoring technologies. Local businesses, particularly in landscaping and sustainable construction, benefit from this trend, thereby strengthening the economic fabric of urban communities.
In conclusion, the socio-economic impacts of green roofs and walls go far beyond mere aesthetic and environmental benefits. These infrastructures serve as catalysts for urban transformation, delivering tangible gains in quality of life, economic development, and property attractiveness.
Critical Evaluation of Barriers to Implementing Green Roofs and Walls: Technical Constraints and Associated Costs
Green roofs and walls provide numerous environmental and socio-economic benefits. However, large-scale implementation faces several challenges and limitations that must be carefully considered.
Technical and Structural Constraints
The primary barrier to adopting green roofs and walls lies in technical and structural issues. These systems add significant load to existing structures, primarily due to the weight of substrates, plants, and retained water. For older or poorly designed buildings, this additional weight may compromise structural integrity, necessitating costly reinforcements or adjustments. Engineers must thoroughly assess the load-bearing capacity of each building before installation, potentially limiting their application, especially in dense urban environments where buildings are often aged or structurally constrained. [17]
Additionally, irrigation systems must be meticulously planned to ensure plant survival. Green roofs, in particular, are exposed to extreme climatic variations such as droughts or heavy rainfall. Installing smart irrigation systems capable of monitoring soil moisture and adjusting watering accordingly becomes essential to prevent substrate drying or waterlogging. However, these systems introduce additional complexity, requiring specialized skills for both installation and maintenance.
Initial Costs and Maintenance
One of the major hurdles in implementing green roofs and walls is the high initial cost. Upfront investments include surface preparation, purchasing substrates and plants, and installing irrigation and drainage systems. While these costs can be offset by long-term savings, particularly in energy efficiency and reduced air-conditioning expenses, the return on investment may take several years.
Plants must be selected for their adaptability to local climatic conditions while requiring minimal maintenance. However, even with careful species selection, issues such as insect infestations, fungal diseases, or substrate deterioration can arise, necessitating frequent and costly interventions.
Local Regulations and Policies
Local regulations and policies play a crucial role in the adoption of green roofs and walls. In some countries, building codes may impose strict restrictions regarding the additional load on existing structures, limiting the installation of green roofs. Furthermore, the lack of standardized guidelines for green roofs and walls may deter developers due to uncertainties surrounding compliance requirements and potential associated costs.
Conversely, some progressive cities have introduced financial incentives to encourage the greening of urban infrastructures. In Paris, for instance, the "Parisculteurs" program [18] offers subsidies and tax reductions for projects incorporating green roofs. Similarly, Toronto’s green roof policy mandates that all new buildings over 2,000 m² must include a certain area of green roofing, with financial penalties for non-compliance. [19] These incentives can accelerate the adoption of green roofs and walls, but they remain limited to a few pioneering cities.
Recommendations for Successful Adoption of Green Roofs and Walls
Best Practices and Plant Selection
The success of green roofs and walls largely depends on appropriate design and careful plant selection. It is crucial to choose plant species that are well-adapted to local climate conditions and require minimal maintenance. For instance, succulent plants such as sedums are often chosen for extensive green roofs due to their ability to withstand drought and efficiently capture water. For green walls, fast-growing and resilient plants like ivy or certain ferns are preferred as they provide dense coverage and good insulation capacity.
The choice of substrate is also vital for the survival of the plants. A lightweight, well-draining substrate that can retain sufficient moisture helps reduce the need for irrigation. Installing automated irrigation systems, combined with moisture sensors, can optimize watering and minimize water waste, particularly in regions with low or irregular rainfall. [20]
Integration into Urban Development Projects
To maximize the benefits of green roofs and walls, it is essential to integrate them during the design phase of construction or renovation projects. Early planning allows for assessing structural constraints and selecting the most suitable solutions for the site context. Collaborating with architects, urban planners, and ecologists from the outset enables the creation of designs that enhance biodiversity, improve thermal insulation, and contribute to rainwater management.
Urban renovation projects present an ideal opportunity to introduce these green infrastructures, especially in areas with limited space for traditional parks and gardens. For example, incorporating green walls in dense neighborhoods can not only enhance aesthetics but also provide environmental benefits such as reducing urban heat islands and filtering particulate pollutants. [21]
Role of Policymakers and Political Incentives
Public policies play a crucial role in promoting green roofs and walls. Policymakers can implement favorable regulations and financial incentive programs to encourage real estate developers to adopt these technologies. For instance, cities like Toronto and Paris have introduced legal mandates for the installation of green roofs on new commercial and residential buildings, with subsidies to cover part of the installation costs. [22] [23]
Fiscal incentives, such as tax credits for sustainable construction, can also motivate investors to integrate these infrastructures into their projects. Additionally, establishing training and certification programs for industry professionals facilitates the adoption of best practices and ensures the quality of installations. By collaborating with local stakeholders, policymakers can develop tailored strategies that address the specific climatic and socio-economic conditions of each region, thereby promoting widespread adoption of green roofs and walls.
Thus, a coordinated and integrated approach involving plant selection, technical design, and public policy is essential to fully realize the benefits of green roofs and walls in our cities.
Conclusion
Green roofs and walls are emerging as innovative and effective solutions to address several contemporary urban challenges. They contribute to enhancing biodiversity, providing thermal insulation for buildings, and sustainably managing rainwater. By offering habitats for pollinators and other species, these infrastructures support greater ecological resilience in urban environments. Additionally, they play a crucial role in mitigating urban heat islands, which helps reduce building energy consumption and promotes a healthier urban environment.
In the future, the significance of green infrastructure will only increase, especially in light of the challenges posed by climate change and rapid urbanization. To maximize their adoption and impact, it is essential for policymakers, urban planners, and real estate developers to integrate these solutions into sustainable urban planning policies. Financial incentives and tailored support programs are necessary to encourage the large-scale implementation of green roofs and walls, ensuring sustainable environmental, economic, and social benefits for future generations.
Interested in learning more about our services? Contact us!
[1] Guide Travaux Toiture. (n.d.). Toiture végétalisée : Types et avantages. Retrieved from https://www.guide-travaux-toiture.be/types-de-toitures/toiture-vegetalisee/
[2] Jardins de Babylone. (n.d.). Mur végétal et jardin vertical : Avantages et installation. Retrieved from https://www.jardinsdebabylone.fr/blog/mur-vegetal-jardin-vertical/
[3] Renewable Energy Hub. (n.d.). History of Green Roofing. Retrieved from https://www.renewableenergyhub.co.uk/main/green-roof-information/history-of-green-roofing
[4] Innovatop Green. (n.d.). The Evolution of Green Roofs. Retrieved from https://www.innovatopgreen.com/en/green-roofs/the-evolution-of-green-roofs/
[5] NParks. (n.d.). City in a Garden: Green Roofs in Singapore. Retrieved from https://www.nparks.gov.sg/-/media/cuge/ebook/citygreen/cg3/cg3_05.pdf
[6] Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution. (2022). Effectiveness of Green Roofs and Green Walls on Energy Consumption and Indoor Comfort in Arid Climates. Retrieved from https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/ecology-and-evolution/articles/10.3389/fevo.2022.804500/full
[7] ResearchGate. (n.d.). Effectiveness of Green Roofs and Green Walls on Energy Consumption. Retrieved from https://www.researchgate.net/publication/328620679_Effectiveness_of_Green_Roofs_and_Green_Walls_on_Energy_Consumption_and_Indoor_Comfort_in_Arid_Climates
[8] Enerzine. (2024). Les toits verts peuvent rafraîchir les villes et économiser de l’énergie : Modélisation. Retrieved from https://www.enerzine.com/les-toits-verts-peuvent-rafraichir-les-villes-et-economiser-de-lenergie-modelisation/84931-2024-02
[9] Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). (n.d.). Heat Island Effect. Retrieved from https://www.epa.gov/heatislands
[10] Gouvernement du Québec. (n.d.). Hambourg : Lutte contre les îlots de chaleur urbains. Retrieved from https://cdn-contenu.quebec.ca/cdn-contenu/adm/min/affaires-municipales/publications/amenagement_territoire/lutte_contre_changements_climatiques/FIC_Hambourg.pdf
[11] Campbell Scientific. (n.d.). Illinois Research Roof Garden. Retrieved from https://www.campbellsci.fr/illinois-research-roof-garden
[12] Twohig-Bennett, C., & Jones, A. (2018). The health benefits of the great outdoors: A systematic review and meta-analysis of greenspace exposure and health outcomes. Environmental Research, 166, 628-637, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envres.2018.06.030.
[13] Beyer, K. M., Kaltenbach, A., Szabo, A., Bogar, S., Nieto, F. J., & Malecki, K. M. (2014). Exposure to neighborhood green space and mental health: Evidence from the survey of the health of Wisconsin. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 11(3), 3453-3472, https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph110303453.
[14] Park, B. J., Tsunetsugu, Y., Kasetani, T., Kagawa, T., & Miyazaki, Y. (2010). The physiological effects of Shinrin-yoku (taking in the forest atmosphere or forest bathing): evidence from field experiments in 24 forests across Japan. Environmental Health and Preventive Medicine, 15(1), 18-26, https://doi.org/10.1007/s12199-009-0086-9.
[15] Maria Manso, Inês Teotónio, Cristina Matos Silva, Carlos Oliveira Cruz,
Green roof and green wall benefits and costs: A review of the quantitative evidence,
Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, Volume 135, 2021, 110111, ISSN 1364-0321, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2020.110111.
[16] Inês Teotónio, Cristina Matos Silva, Carlos Oliveira Cruz, Economics of green roofs and green walls: A literature review, Sustainable Cities and Society, Volume 69, 2021, 102781, ISSN 2210-6707, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scs.2021.102781.
[17] Soprema Entreprises. (n.d.). Comment entretenir une toiture végétalisée toute l'année. Retrieved from https://www.soprema-entreprises.fr/comment-entretenir-toiture-vegetalisee-toute-l-annee/
[18] Ministère de la Transition Écologique. (2019). Monographie des innovations urbaines : Parisculteurs. Retrieved from https://www.ecocites.logement.gouv.fr/IMG/pdf/190321_monographie_iso_parisculteurs.pdf
[19] City of Toronto. (n.d.). Green Roofs. Retrieved from https://www.toronto.ca/city-government/planning-development/official-plan-guidelines/green-roofs/
[20] Snodgrass, E. C., & McIntyre, L. (2010). The Green Roof Manual: A Professional Guide to Design, Installation, and Maintenance. Timber Press.
[21] Oberndorfer, E., Lundholm, J., Bass, B., Coffman, R. R., Doshi, H., Dunnett, N., & Rowe, B. (2007). Green Roofs as Urban Ecosystems: Ecological Structures, Functions, and Services. BioScience, 57(10), 823-833, https://doi.org/10.1641/B571005.
[22] City of Toronto. (2023). Green Roof Bylaw. Retrieved from https://www.toronto.ca/services-payments/water-environment/green-roofs/
[23] Ville de Paris. (2022). Programme Parisculteurs. Retrieved from https://www.parisculteurs.paris.fr
Witten by Mehdi BELAHOUCINE
